Tenth Circuit, United States v. Schear: a corroborated informant's tip and the automobile exception

On November 17, 2026, a Tenth Circuit panel unanimously affirmed the denial of a motion to suppress, holding that corroborated information from a confidential informant gave officers probable cause to search a vehicle without a warrant.

CourtNovember 17, 20264 min readThe Constilumen record

What happened

On November 17, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit decided United States v. Schear, No. 25-8043, in a published opinion. The panel affirmed the denial of Wade Earl Schear's motions to suppress about two pounds of methamphetamine found in a borrowed Volkswagen that Platte County, Wyoming, sheriff's deputies stopped and searched in June 2024. Schear was convicted in the District of Wyoming of possession of methamphetamine with intent to distribute and sentenced to 300 months' imprisonment; on appeal he challenged only the suppression rulings. Judge Hartz wrote the opinion for a unanimous panel that also included Judges Matheson and Federico. There was no separate opinion.

What the opinion says

The district court had upheld the search on three alternative grounds: that the state search warrant was valid, that officers relied on it in good faith, and that the automobile exception to the Fourth Amendment's warrant requirement applied regardless of the warrant. The government waived any reliance on a drug-dog alert. The Tenth Circuit decided the case on the automobile exception alone, which, the opinion states, allows a warrantless vehicle search "if they have probable cause to believe it contains contraband."

Schear argued that the officers, even collectively, lacked probable cause because the confidential informant was not reliable: the informant had a criminal record, had recently been arrested, faced a possible lengthy sentence, and had not managed to arrange a controlled purchase from Schear. The court treated those points as "only one factor in weighing the totality of the circumstances," and held that the balance "tilts squarely toward crediting the informant in this case."

The opinion lists what investigators corroborated: the informant's tips had supported two controlled purchases from another man, Ronald Fox; the informant correctly gave Schear's address and vehicle and identified him in a photograph; GPS data placed Schear's truck at suspected drug locations; and the informant's account of Schear's trip, that he would borrow the Volkswagen, drive to Colorado, stay overnight after the car developed mechanical trouble, and return to Wyoming, was confirmed by tracker data and by a deputy who saw the car traveling about 20 miles per hour in a 70 mile-per-hour zone, smoking, with its hazard lights on.

The court compared the facts with Illinois v. Gates (1983) and Draper v. United States (1959), in which corroborated details of innocent travel supported crediting an informant's claim of drug activity. On Schear's argument that the corroborated facts had innocent explanations, the opinion states that when an informant describes "future actions of third parties ordinarily not easily predicted," the evidence "is probative even if the activities have potentially innocent explanations." It added that "all that probable cause requires is sufficient corroboration for a reasonable officer to credit the informant," noting that "although some of the informant's assertions were never corroborated, a number of them were corroborated, and none of the informant's assertions proved incorrect."

The court concluded: "Because officers had probable cause, the automobile exception permitted a warrantless search of the vehicle." It did not address the warrant's validity or the good-faith ground.

The other side

The panel was unanimous. As the opinion describes them, Schear's arguments were that the informant's record, recent arrest and possible sentence gave a motive to lie; that the failed attempt at a controlled purchase from him weighed against the informant's credibility; that Gates stands for the proposition that an uncorroborated tip alone is insufficient for probable cause; and that the facts officers relied on, such as driving to Colorado and back and stopping near certain houses, had innocent explanations. The opinion also acknowledges that there was "no direct confirmation" of some of the informant's reports, including that he had seen Schear with drugs.

Where it sits in the record

The Fourth Amendment protects "the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures." In Illinois v. Gates, 462 U.S. 213 (1983), the Supreme Court adopted a totality-of-the-circumstances approach to informants' tips, calling for "a balanced assessment of the relative weights of all the various indicia of reliability (and unreliability) attending an informant's tip"; Justices Brennan, Marshall and Stevens dissented. The record has also covered the Eleventh Circuit's November 12 decision in Kelly v. Jett, which addressed an anonymous tip, corroboration and probable cause, and the Sixth Circuit's November 6 decision in United States v. Cook on challenges to a warrant affidavit.

Sources

Record updates report what happened and take no side. Signed analysis is kept apart, in Positions. Published November 17, 2026.

Record updates by email. Daily or weekly.

New decisions, orders and votes as they enter the record, each with its primary source, on the schedule you choose.

How often