What happened
On November 17, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit decided Brown v. Saint-Gobain Performance Plastics Corp., No. 24-1869. Property owners in and around Merrimack, New Hampshire, allege that Saint-Gobain's Merrimack facility released airborne PFOA that reached the municipal water supply and private wells. In December 2023 the U.S. District Court for the District of New Hampshire certified a class on liability for the plaintiffs' negligence, negligent-failure-to-warn and trespass claims, and planned to try damages separately. Saint-Gobain appealed under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(f).
The panel (Chief Judge Barron and Judges Kayatta and Montecalvo) reversed in part and affirmed in part. Judge Kayatta wrote the opinion. No judge wrote separately.
What the opinion says
Most of the opinion applies Rule 23(b)(3)'s predominance requirement under New Hampshire tort law.
- Negligence-based claims: certification reversed. For these claims the plaintiffs must show that the PFOA harmed each property, and the court found that injury and causation "largely turn[] on individual questions." The plaintiffs' experts agree that other sources "may have contributed to localized contamination," and the court held that the plaintiffs "have not shown how the effects of this localized contamination from alternative sources could be accounted for on a common basis."
- Trespass claim: certification affirmed. Under New Hampshire law, trespass liability requires only an intentional intrusion, not harm. Whether Saint-Gobain's PFOA reached every property in the class area therefore turns on the plaintiffs' expert evidence, and "its validity is itself a common question." The court noted that Saint-Gobain had not preserved any argument that invisible particulate matter requires an additional showing, and it declined to decide that state-law question on its own.
- Rule 23(c)(4). The court said Saint-Gobain's argument about "issue classes" misread the certification order, so it left open whether a court may certify part of a cause of action under that rule.
The constitutional question. Saint-Gobain argued that splitting trial between a liability jury and later damages proceedings would violate the Seventh Amendment's Reexamination Clause, because issues of proximate cause, injury and damages overlap with negligence. The court quoted the Amendment: "no fact tried by a jury shall be otherwise re-examined in any Court of the United States." It reasoned that the negligence-based claims were already decertified, and that proximate causation and injury for trespass can be resolved on a common basis. It held: "we cannot agree with Saint-Gobain that the district court's certification order -- whittled down to plaintiffs' trespass claim -- necessarily contravenes the Seventh Amendment."
The holding is limited to the order as narrowed to the trespass claim. The court also noted that individual damages adjudications must remain "'protective of defendants' Seventh Amendment and due process rights,'" quoting its own precedent. It did not decide whether individual damages in this case would be too burdensome, because Saint-Gobain acknowledged at argument that "if all elements of liability are established, the law is well settled that damages can be different."
Where it sits in the record
On the Seventh Amendment point the opinion relies on two Seventh Circuit decisions. In Matter of Rhone-Poulenc Rorer, Inc., 51 F.3d 1293 (7th Cir. 1995), that court suggested that bifurcated class proceedings can violate the Amendment when the first jury decides only negligence and later juries take up overlapping issues. In Pella Corp. v. Saltzman, 606 F.3d 391 (7th Cir. 2010), it rejected a Seventh Amendment argument where individual juries would not reexamine class issues. On issue classes, the First Circuit set the Fifth Circuit's reading in Castano v. American Tobacco Co. (1996) against the Seventh Circuit's in Jacks v. DirectSat USA (2024), and decided neither. In an earlier stage of this case, the Supreme Court of New Hampshire answered a certified question in 2023: New Hampshire does not recognize a cause of action or remedy for medical monitoring. The case returns to the district court for proceedings on the trespass class.
Sources
Record updates report what happened and take no side. Signed analysis is kept apart, in Positions. Published November 17, 2026.