What happened
On November 20, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit decided Brown v. Adamson, No. 25-730, in a published opinion. The panel (Circuit Judges Milan D. Smith, Jr. and Eric C. Tung, and District Judge Yvette Kane of the Middle District of Pennsylvania, sitting by designation) reversed the District of Nevada's denial of qualified immunity to two prison doctors, Drs. Kim Adamson and Dana Marks, and remanded with instructions to grant it. Judge M. Smith wrote the opinion. No judge wrote separately.
Jason Brown, then held by the Nevada Department of Corrections, sued the two doctors under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, alleging deliberate indifference to his medical needs in violation of the Eighth Amendment. After a 2018 facial fracture and surgery, he complained for years of head pain, vertigo, nausea and vision problems. Dr. Marks noted in 2020 and again in 2021 that Brown should see an ear, nose and throat specialist, but the record does not show the referral was taken to the prison's Utilization Review Committee until about May 2023, after the district court granted a preliminary injunction directing that Brown be seen by a neurologist and an ENT. The district court later denied summary judgment to the doctors, finding genuine disputes of fact on deliberate indifference.
What the opinion says
The panel addressed only the second prong of qualified immunity, whether the law was clearly established, and did not decide whether the doctors' conduct violated the Eighth Amendment. It relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Zorn v. Linton, 607 U.S. 568 (2026), which, the opinion says, "emphasized that there is a high bar" to finding law clearly established. In light of Zorn, the panel wrote, "we are mindful of the requisite high degrees of both (1) specificity in the established formulation of the law and (2) similarity between the facts of the prior and instant cases in order to clearly establish the law."
The panel then considered the three Ninth Circuit precedents on which the district court and Brown relied:
- **Hoptowit v. Ray (1982)*, which the district court read to require that prison doctors "be able to treat medical problems or to refer prisoners to others who can." The panel wrote that Hoptowit* was a class action about prison conditions that "only cursorily addressed" referrals and "merely articulates the general principle that when medical care is outside the expertise of prison staff, they should seek outside specialists."
- **Stewart v. Aranas (2022)**, which Brown cited for the rule that officials violate the Constitution "when they persist in a treatment known to be ineffective." The panel found it "more specific but similarly inapposite," because the officials there "never deviated" from a "wait and see" plan, while the record here shows the doctors "considered a variety of potential diagnoses and engaged various diagnostic tools."
- **Snow v. McDaniel (2012)*, which Brown cited for the rule that ignoring specialist recommendations for years raises a jury question. The panel noted that in Snow* the review committee repeatedly denied outside doctors' surgical recommendations, while here the record does not show any referral request for Brown was ever denied.
The panel concluded: "Because there is no clearly established law defining the point at which a delay in making an outside medical referral constitutes deliberate indifference under the Eighth Amendment, we reverse and remand with instructions to grant qualified immunity to Drs. Adamson and Marks."
The other side
No judge dissented. The position the panel rejected is the one taken by the district court and by Brown, as the opinion recounts it. The district court held that Hoptowit clearly established that prison doctors must "be able to treat medical problems or to refer prisoners to others who can." On appeal, Brown argued that circuit precedent also establishes that officials "violate the [C]onstitution when they persist in a treatment known to be ineffective" (Stewart) and that "ignoring specialist recommendations for years raises a jury question on deliberate indifference" (Snow). The opinion also acknowledges that "the delay in making the referral to an outside medical provider was more protracted in this case than in Snow," while noting that Brown did not rely on Snow for the permitted length of delay.
Where it sits in the record
The opinion applies the Eighth Amendment deliberate-indifference standard, under which "mere delay" of care, "without more," is not enough (Shapley v. Nevada Board of State Prison Commissioners, 1985), and the two-prong qualified-immunity framework of Pearson v. Callahan (2009), which lets courts decide either prong first. It applies Zorn v. Linton (2026), in which, as the opinion recounts, the Supreme Court reversed a denial of qualified immunity to an officer who used a rear wristlock on a protester at a sit-in at the Vermont state capitol.
Sources
Record updates report what happened and take no side. Signed analysis is kept apart, in Positions. Published November 21, 2026.