Ninth Circuit, A.M.A.S. v. Mullin: stay granted of an order to facilitate a return after third-country removal

On November 20, 2026, a Ninth Circuit panel granted the government a stay pending appeal of a district court order, based on the Fifth Amendment's Due Process Clause, requiring it to facilitate the return of a man removed to Equatorial Guinea. Judge Graber dissented in large part.

CourtNovember 20, 20264 min readThe Constilumen record

What happened

On November 20, 2026, a panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit (Judges Graber, Bennett and H.A. Thomas) granted the federal government's emergency motion to stay, pending appeal, a District of Arizona judgment in A.M.A.S. v. Mullin, No. 26-6950. The order is per curiam and published. Judge Graber dissented in large part.

According to the facts set out in the dissent, which cites the district court's findings, the plaintiff is an Egyptian national who became a lawful permanent resident in 2021 and was ordered removed to Egypt in 2025 but granted deferral of removal under the Convention Against Torture. On April 28, 2026, he was removed to Equatorial Guinea. On October 6, 2026, the district court ruled solely on his constitutional claim, held that his removal "without notice of the country of removal and a meaningful opportunity to raise a country-specific fear-based claim" violated his right to procedural due process under the Fifth Amendment, and ordered the government to "facilitate" his return to the United States. It later issued further orders directing particular steps. The district court did not reach his Administrative Procedure Act claim.

What the order says

The per curiam order applies the four stay factors from Nken v. Holder: likelihood of success on the merits, irreparable injury to the applicant, injury to other parties, and the public interest. It states: "Having considered the Nken factors, we find that they support the issuance of a stay. The government's motion for a stay pending appeal is therefore GRANTED."

The order gives no further reasons. It does not decide the merits of the due process claim, which remain before the court on appeal.

The other side

Judge Graber dissented "in large part from the order granting a stay." The dissent would have granted a stay "only to the extent that the district court's orders exceed the remedy described in Abrego Garcia," and otherwise would have let the district court require the government to facilitate the plaintiff's return while the appeal proceeds.

On irreparable harm, which the dissent treated as dispositive, Judge Graber wrote that the district court's order "requires the government to facilitate the return of a single individual from a single country," and that "the Supreme Court in Abrego Garcia blessed precisely this remedy in precisely this context." The dissent rejected the government's argument that the Supreme Court's September 29, 2026 stay in Department of Homeland Security v. D.V.D. "squarely controls," reasoning that the district court in D.V.D. set aside the Department's third-country removal guidance under the APA and granted classwide relief, while this case rests on an individual constitutional claim.

On likelihood of success, the dissent addressed five arguments the government raised: that Rule 23 and the pending class action bar the suit, that res judicata applies, that the district court lacked jurisdiction (an argument the dissent said the court rejected in Ibarra-Perez v. United States), that the government may remove a person to a third country without notice or a fear interview, and that the remedy exceeded the court's authority. It concluded the government "has not made a strong showing of a likelihood of success." Judge Graber agreed that "the government is likely correct that the court's later orders overstepped," which is why the dissent would have stayed those portions.

On the equities, Judge Graber described the district court's unrebutted findings that the plaintiff had been held under armed guard, threatened at gunpoint, and "arrested, beaten, and held incommunicado," and concluded that "the equities strongly disfavor a stay."

Where it sits in the record

The dissent ties this case to D.V.D., in which the Supreme Court granted a stay and certiorari on September 29, 2026, and to the Court's November 13, 2026 grant of review in Mullin v. Refugee and Immigrant Center, which this record reported, including on whether an immigration provision bars classwide relief. It also relies on the Supreme Court's 2025 order in Noem v. Abrego Garcia, which approved a district court order requiring the government to "facilitate" the return of a person removed to El Salvador.

Sources

Record updates report what happened and take no side. Signed analysis is kept apart, in Positions. Published November 22, 2026.

Record updates by email. Daily or weekly.

New decisions, orders and votes as they enter the record, each with its primary source, on the schedule you choose.

How often