Fifth Circuit, Tuttle v. Gallegos: the Harding Street raid shootings, qualified immunity and a 12-5 vote denying rehearing en banc

On November 16, 2026, a Fifth Circuit panel substituted a new opinion holding that a Houston officer who shot two residents during a 2019 no-knock raid is entitled to qualified immunity on Fourth Amendment excessive-force claims. The full court voted 12-5 against rehearing en banc, and four judges dissented from that denial.

CourtNovember 16, 20264 min readThe Constilumen record

What happened

On November 16, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit issued two published rulings in Tuttle v. Gallegos, No. 25-20132, an interlocutory appeal from the Southern District of Texas. The case arises from the January 28, 2019 execution of a no-knock search warrant by Houston Police Department officers at 7815 Harding Street, during which Officer Felipe Gallegos shot and killed residents Dennis Tuttle and Rhogena Nicholas. The opinion states that the officer who obtained the warrant "falsely claimed in an affidavit" that a confidential informant had bought heroin at the house.

The estates sued under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, alleging excessive force under the Fourth Amendment. The district court denied Gallegos's motion for summary judgment on qualified immunity, finding material fact disputes.

In the first ruling, the court denied rehearing en banc. Five judges voted to rehear the case (Chief Judge Elrod and Judges Graves, Higginson, Willett and Douglas) and twelve voted against (Judges Jones, Smith, Stewart, Richman, Southwick, Haynes, Ho, Duncan, Engelhardt, Oldham, Wilson and Ramirez). In the second, the panel (Judges Jones, Clement and Richman) withdrew its earlier opinion and substituted a new one, written by Judge Clement, which reverses the district court and holds that Gallegos is entitled to qualified immunity. No panel member wrote separately.

What the opinion says

The panel said it could review only whether the fact disputes the district court identified were material, and it accepted the plaintiffs' version of disputed facts for that purpose.

Nicholas. The panel assumed, as the plaintiffs contend, that Officer Frank Medina had already been taken outside and that Nicholas was not reaching for his weapon. It relied on the undisputed fact that Officer Cedell Lovings lay wounded in the doorway, "a very short distance from Nicholas," and held that Medina's location was therefore not material. Applying Graham v. Connor and the Supreme Court's instruction in Barnes v. Felix (2025) to consider "facts and events leading up to the climactic moment," the panel held: "An objectively reasonable officer would have been justified in making a split-second decision to use deadly force against Nicholas given her close proximity to a wounded officer under these tense, uncertain, and rapidly evolving circumstances." It noted that its circuit's earlier "moment-of-threat" doctrine "is no longer good law" after Barnes.

Tuttle. The plaintiffs challenged only the final two shots. The panel assumed that Tuttle's earlier wounds left him unable to hold a gun, but held that "there is no evidence that Gallegos would have known that fact" because Tuttle's back was to the door, and that his movements did not show he "had clearly given himself up," quoting Plumhoff v. Rickard. It wrote: "The Fourth Amendment's excessive force jurisprudence does not require police officers to diagnose a suspect's medical condition during an active gunfight in which officers had been shot."

The panel concluded that, on both claims, there was no constitutional violation, and reversed the denial of summary judgment.

The other side

Judge Graves, joined by Chief Judge Elrod and Judges Higginson and Douglas, dissented from the denial of rehearing en banc.

On Nicholas, he wrote that under the plaintiffs' facts she "was unarmed, seated on a couch, and did not resist," and that Gallegos gave no warning before shooting. He argued that the cases the panel cited "specifically turn on an action, usually 'reaching,'" and that the panel identified no such action: "Simply being near an officer does not justify the use of deadly force." Citing Tennessee v. Garner, he concluded that the law "is clearly established that officers cannot use deadly force on a non-threatening suspect."

On Tuttle, he described the plaintiffs' evidence that Tuttle had sustained seven wounds, was shot in the buttocks while dropping to the ground, and was shot in the back of the head or neck twenty seconds later as he raised himself on his elbows. Relying on the circuit's decision in Mason v. Lafayette City-Parish Consolidated Government (2015), he wrote that a reasonable jury could find Tuttle "would have appeared incapacitated to an objectively reasonable officer." He concluded that the panel's opinion "ignores that balance in favor of an absolute shield for officials over accountability where it is due," and that "this case should have proceeded to trial, and Officer Gallegos' actions should have been evaluated by a jury."

Where it sits in the record

The panel's analysis applies Barnes v. Felix, 605 U.S. 73 (2025), in which the Supreme Court held, as the Court's opinion summary puts it, that the Fifth Circuit's moment-of-threat rule "improperly narrows the Fourth Amendment analysis of police use of force." This appeal concerns only Gallegos. The opinion records that the district court's rulings left claims pending against two other officers, Stephen Bryant and Gerald Goines, the officer who obtained the warrant.

Sources

Record updates report what happened and take no side. Signed analysis is kept apart, in Positions. Published November 16, 2026.

Record updates by email. Daily or weekly.

New decisions, orders and votes as they enter the record, each with its primary source, on the schedule you choose.

How often